Church Tensions: United Methodist Exodus

U.S. Media

•

14 days

Summary

sources
40
Narrative Items
50
Bottom Line Up Front

40 sources in U.S. Media are amplifying 50 narrative items relating to the narrative of a property dispute between the United Methodist Church and the Global Methodist Church. This conflict highlights broader themes of religious division over LGBT issues, illustrating how theological disagreements can lead to significant institutional and financial ramifications.

Reviewing a number of the most relevant narrative items indicates that the Christian Post characterizes the mediation between the United Methodist Church (UMC) and the Global Methodist Church (GMC) in a generally positive light, focusing on the hope for resolution and reconciliation. The language employed is notably supportive, using phrases such as "constructive dialogue" and "a pathway to peace," which conveys an optimistic outlook on the mediation process. However, there are subtle indicators of bias, as the article frames the UMC's recent changes regarding LGBT issues as a source of division, casting the GMC as a refuge for more conservative congregations. Comparatively, while the Christian Post emphasizes the potential for unity, other sources might highlight the emotional turmoil and conflict within the congregation, using more emotionally charged words to illustrate the crisis. This contrast showcases how different outlets may either aim to soothe or amplify tensions based on their editorial slants, affecting public perception of the events.

About This Module

The U.S. Media module tracks a broad range of American media sources, including major television, cable, print, and online organizations.

Read more...
Read Less...

Sources

Sources by Type
Sources of these types represent most of the amplification activity around this narrative
sources by Volume
These sources are amplifying the most items involved in this narrative. Click to see details of each source's narrative activity.
Top sources
Day-by-day volumetric activity of sources amplifying the most items around this narrative
Christian Post
6% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
The Baltimore Sun City Paper
4% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Texas Tribune
4% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Portland Press-Herald
4% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Baptist News Global
4% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Capital Gazette
4% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
ArcaMax
4% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Fort Worth Star-Telegram
4% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Oregonian
4% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
NBC News
2% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Read more...
Read Less...

Top Items

These narrative items are the most relevant and/or the most amplified. Click to see details and suggested messages.
Amplifiers:
Christian Post
christianpost.com
Liberian lawmakers overseeing mediation between UMC, Global Methodist churches amid dispute   
Liberian lawmakers mediate a property dispute between the United Methodist Church (UMC) and the Global Methodist Church (GMC). The conflict stems from the UMC's recent changes regarding LGBT issues, causing many conservative congregations, including some in Liberia, to join the GMC. Mediation aims to de-escalate tensions and determine asset ownership.
Amplifiers:
Christian Post
christianpost.com
UMC bishop, other Methodists attacked in Nigeria while doing ministry work
In Nigeria, United Methodist Bishop Ande Emmanuel and his entourage were attacked during ministry work. This violence follows ongoing conflict between the UMC and the Global Methodist Church over property and affiliation, exacerbated by Nigeria's existing issues with religious extremism and violence. The UMC condemns the attack and calls for peace.
Amplifiers:
The Baltimore Sun City Paper
baltimoresun.com
Damon Evans reportedly leaving Maryland to become athletic director at SMU
Maryland athletic director Damon Evans is leaving for a six-year deal at SMU, triggering a whirlwind week for the university. His departure, costing Maryland $500,000, follows a mixed tenure marked by facility upgrades, financial challenges, and coaching changes. The move complicates contract negotiations for Maryland's basketball coach.
Amplifiers:
Baptist News Global
baptistnews.com
‘Economic Community’ teaches United Methodists all wealth belongs to God – Baptist News Global
United Methodist economic theology, rooted in John Wesley's teachings, asserts that all wealth belongs to God. Their Social Principles advocate for equitable economies, opposing poverty, inequality, and exploitative practices like human trafficking. This includes responsible consumerism, fair labor, and corporate accountability, though internal inconsistencies remain, such as continued fossil fuel investments.
Amplifiers:
WRAL Raleigh
wral.com
Girlfriend claims Green Beret planned to leave his wife before his disappearance, death :: WRAL.com
Former Green Beret Clint Bonnell disappeared after telling his girlfriend he'd informed his wife of his plans to divorce her. His remains were later found dismembered, and his wife, Shana Cloud, has been arrested and charged with murder and concealing his death.
Amplifiers:
Fayetteville Observer
fayobserver.com
Cumberland's tax people WANT you to appeal if you disagree on property value | Opinion
Cumberland County residents received new property valuations, causing some "sticker shock". Officials held meetings to explain the mass appraisal process and encourage appeals if values seem inaccurate. The deadline for informal appeals was March 24th, with formal appeals due between March 25th and May 28th. The Board of Equalization and Review makes final decisions starting in April.
Amplifiers:
WTVD Raleigh-Durham
abc11.com
Woman accused of killing Green Beret husband secretly disposed of his body, court documents say
Shana Cloud is accused of murdering her Green Beret husband, Clinton Bonnell. Only his torso was found in a pond; authorities are still searching for the rest of his body. Court documents suggest Cloud secretly disposed of the remains after Bonnell sought a divorce. The prosecution cites the pending divorce as a possible motive. Cloud's bond was denied, and she faces capital punishment.
Amplifiers:
Portland Press-Herald
pressherald.com
Obituary: Lillian (Marshall) Bartlett
Lillian Marshall Bartlett (1925-2025) passed away at 99 after a short illness. A Kennebunkport resident since 1978, she was active in her church, community, and family, known for her knitting, Scrabble skills, and volunteer work. A memorial service is scheduled for April 5th.
Amplifiers:
The Des Moines Register
desmoinesregister.com
UnityPoint nurses demand health system stop trying to bust up their bid to form a union
UnityPoint Health nurses in Des Moines are pushing to unionize with Teamsters Local 90, citing concerns about pay, working conditions, and patient care. The hospital system is accused of "union-busting" tactics, including hiring anti-union consultants, prompting four NLRB complaints. Nurses are demanding an end to these alleged unfair labor practices.
Amplifiers:
Fort Worth Star-Telegram
star-telegram.com
Texas’ biggest health insurer may drop these Tarrant County hospitals from some plans
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas and Southwestern Health Resources must agree on a new contract by April 1st. Failure to do so will remove over two dozen North Texas hospitals, including major facilities, from seven Blue Cross plans, potentially impacting many Obamacare users. While negotiations continue, concerns exist about the hospitals' removal from online provider databases.
Read more...

Entities

Tap or click for details
These entities are mentioned most frequently in the narratives highlighted in this brief. Click to see details of narrative activity related to each one.
Narratives
Conservative Congregations Joining GMC
The trend of conservative congregations leaving UMC for GMC due to differing views on LGBT issues.
Tensions Between UMC and GMC
The rising tensions between the two denominations as a result of the property dispute.
Controversies
LGBT Issues in UMC
Recent changes in the UMC's stance on LGBT matters leading to division within the church.
Property Dispute
Conflict over the ownership of church properties between UMC and GMC.
Denominations
United Methodist Church (UMC)
A mainline Protestant denomination that has faced internal conflict over LGBT issues.
Global Methodist Church (GMC)
A newly formed denomination that appeals to conservative congregations leaving the UMC.
Decisions
Mediation Decision
The decision by Liberian lawmakers to mediate the property dispute.
People
Liberian Lawmakers
Members of the legislative body in Liberia involved in mediating the dispute.
Narratives
Conservative Congregations Joining GMC
The trend of conservative congregations leaving UMC for GMC due to differing views on LGBT issues.
Tensions Between UMC and GMC
The rising tensions between the two denominations as a result of the property dispute.
Controversies
LGBT Issues in UMC
Recent changes in the UMC's stance on LGBT matters leading to division within the church.
Property Dispute
Conflict over the ownership of church properties between UMC and GMC.
Denominations
United Methodist Church (UMC)
A mainline Protestant denomination that has faced internal conflict over LGBT issues.
Global Methodist Church (GMC)
A newly formed denomination that appeals to conservative congregations leaving the UMC.
Decisions
Mediation Decision
The decision by Liberian lawmakers to mediate the property dispute.
People
Liberian Lawmakers
Members of the legislative body in Liberia involved in mediating the dispute.

Context

Liberia, a nation founded by freed American slaves, has a complex demographic and social landscape. The population is predominantly Christian, with a significant portion belonging to the United Methodist Church (UMC). The recent schism within the UMC over LGBT issues reflects broader global debates on social values, particularly in conservative societies like Liberia, where traditional views on sexuality are prevalent. This conflict has led to the emergence of the Global Methodist Church (GMC), attracting congregations that oppose the UMC's progressive stance.

Economically, Liberia faces challenges, including high unemployment and reliance on agriculture and natural resources. The church dispute could exacerbate social divisions, impacting community cohesion and economic stability, especially in rural areas where churches often play a central role in social services and local governance.

Politically, Liberia has a history of instability, including a civil war that ended in 2003. The current government must navigate these religious tensions carefully to maintain peace and avoid potential unrest. Lawmakers mediating the dispute are tasked with balancing the interests of both factions while ensuring that the resolution does not lead to further polarization.

Geographically, Liberia's location along the West African coast makes it vulnerable to external influences, including the spread of ideologies from more liberal societies. National security concerns are heightened by the potential for social unrest stemming from this religious conflict, which could destabilize an already fragile political environment. The outcome of this mediation will be crucial in determining not only the future of the churches involved but also the broader implications for social harmony and political stability in Liberia.
Read more...
Read Less...
World Events
Tap or roll over dots to see representative headlines
Stock & Crypto Dynamics