Church Tensions: United Methodist Exodus | Right Bias

U.S. Media

•

14 days

Summary

sources
12
Narrative Items
14
Bottom Line Up Front

12 sources in U.S. Media are amplifying 14 narrative items relating to the narrative that connect Christianity and democracy through critiques of Marxism, defenses of democratic capitalism, concerns over clerical power, and the historical role of Methodism. These themes collectively shape Mark Tooley’s activism and leadership at the Institute on Religion and Democracy.

Reviewing a number of the most relevant narrative items indicates that World Magazine portrays Mark Tooley's views on Christianity and democracy in a positive light, emphasizing his thoughtful engagement with influential thinkers. The language used is analytical and respectful, highlighting Tooley's intellectual journey through key authors without resorting to hyperbole or emotionally charged terms. The coverage reflects a clear editorial alignment with conservative Christian values, particularly in praising critiques of Marxism and defenses of democratic capitalism. There is an evident bias towards affirming Tooley’s activism as a necessary response to perceived threats within mainline denominations, positioning him as a principled figure defending religious and democratic ideals. Unlike sensationalist portrayals, this source maintains a measured tone, focusing on ideological foundations rather than dramatizing conflicts.

About This Module

The U.S. Media module tracks a broad range of American media sources, including major television, cable, print, and online organizations.

View More
View Less

Sources

Sources by Type
Sources of these types represent most of the amplification activity around this narrative
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0Chart context menuRight-​Center Bias ​64.3%​Right-​Center Bias ​64.3%Right Bias ​35.7%​Right Bias ​35.7%
sources by Volume
These sources are amplifying the most items involved in this narrative. Click to see details of each source's narrative activity.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0Chart context menuFree​Republic ​21.4%​Free​Republic ​21.4%World​Magazine ​7.1%​World​Magazine ​7.1%Daily Herald​​7.1%​Daily Herald​​7.1%Chronicles​Magazine ​7.1%​Chronicles​Magazine ​7.1%The​Algemeiner​Journal ​7.1%​The​Algemeiner​Journal ​7.1%Boston​Herald ​7.1%​Boston​Herald ​7.1%Greeley​Tribune ​7.1%​Greeley​Tribune ​7.1%Willoughby​News-​Herald ​7.1%​Willoughby​News-​Herald ​7.1%Los Angeles​Daily News ​7.1%​Los Angeles​Daily News ​7.1%Orange​County​Register ​7.1%​Orange​County​Register ​7.1%Salem Radio​Network​News ​7.1%​Salem Radio​Network​News ​7.1%Washington​Times ​7.1%​Washington​Times ​7.1%
Top sources
Day-by-day volumetric activity of sources amplifying the most items around this narrative
Free Republic
21% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
Washington Times
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
Boston Herald
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
Daily Herald
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
Greeley Tribune
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
Los Angeles Daily News
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
Orange County Register
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
Salem Radio Network News
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
The Algemeiner Journal
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
Willoughby News-Herald
7% of the items in this brief were amplified by this source.
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 18May 20May 22May 24May 26
View More
View Less

Top Items

These narrative items are the most relevant and/or the most amplified. Click to see details and suggested messages.
Amplifiers:
World Magazine
wng.org
Christianity and democracy
Mark Tooley's views on the intersection of Christianity and democracy were shaped by several key authors. He cites the Robbs' exposé of mainline denominations' Marxist leanings, Novak's defense of democratic capitalism, Neuhaus' critique of unchecked clerical power, and Weber's articulation of Methodism's democratizing principles. Butterfield's emphasis on historical patience and self-limitation further informed his perspective. These works led Tooley to activism and his current role at the Institute on Religion and Democracy.
Amplifiers:
Free Republic
freerepublic.com
DA drops charges against woman whose baby was found in Whataburger toilet
Charges against a Texas woman who was found in a Whataburger restroom with her deceased preterm baby were dropped. The medical examiner determined the baby was stillborn, not born alive, and there was insufficient evidence the woman attempted to flush the baby. The baby received a proper funeral.
Amplifiers:
Free Republic
freerepublic.com
Episcopalians Find Strange Old Book Hidden Under Pew
An Episcopal church discovered a "Holy Bible" under a pew, causing alarm among parishioners unfamiliar with its contents. Church leaders fear infiltration by right-wing religious extremists due to the Bible's unfamiliar verses and perceived "dangerous fundamental values." The incident sparked an investigation to identify the book's owner and purge any hint of Christianity.
Amplifiers:
Free Republic
freerepublic.com
Joe Biden’s Dept of Justice – Merrick Garland was AG In Name Only for a Specific Reason
This article claims Merrick Garland's Attorney General role was a strategic move to allow Ketanji Brown Jackson's Supreme Court appointment. The author alleges that Obama's team, particularly Deputy AG Lisa Monaco, actually ran the DOJ, using it to target political opponents and facilitate a plan involving Holder and Lynch. The ultimate goal was to secure Brown Jackson's place on the Supreme Court.
Amplifiers:
Washington Times
washingtontimes.com
Fire at historic Black church in Memphis was intentionally set, investigators say
Investigators determined that a fire severely damaging Memphis' historic Clayborn Temple, a key location in the 1968 sanitation workers' strike and visited by Martin Luther King Jr., was arson. The church, undergoing renovations, suffered interior damage, but efforts to salvage the facade continue. The act is mourned but won't break the community's spirit.
Amplifiers:
Salem Radio Network News
srnnews.com
Fire at historic Black church in Memphis was intentionally set, investigators say
Investigators determined arson caused a fire that severely damaged Memphis's historic Clayborn Temple, a key location during the 1968 sanitation workers' strike and a site visited by Martin Luther King Jr. The church, undergoing a multi-million dollar restoration, suffered interior damage, though some exterior elements might be salvaged. The fire is under investigation.
Amplifiers:
Boston Herald
bostonherald.com
Fire at historic Black church in Memphis was intentionally set, investigators say
Investigators determined arson caused a fire that severely damaged Memphis' historic Clayborn Temple, a key location during the 1968 sanitation workers' strike and linked to Martin Luther King Jr. The church, undergoing a $25 million restoration, suffered interior damage, though efforts are underway to salvage the facade.
Amplifiers:
Willoughby News-Herald
news-herald.com
Fire at historic Black church in Memphis was intentionally set, investigators say
Investigators determined the fire that severely damaged Memphis' historic Clayborn Temple, a key location during the 1968 sanitation workers' strike and linked to Martin Luther King Jr., was arson. The church, undergoing a multi-million dollar renovation, suffered interior damage, though efforts are underway to salvage the facade. The cause remains under investigation.
Amplifiers:
Greeley Tribune
greeleytribune.com
Fire at historic Black church in Memphis was intentionally set, investigators say
Investigators determined arson caused a fire at Memphis' historic Clayborn Temple, a key location during the 1968 sanitation workers' strike and linked to Martin Luther King Jr. The intentionally set blaze severely damaged the church, currently undergoing a $25 million restoration. The investigation continues.
Amplifiers:
Los Angeles Daily News
dailynews.com
Fire at historic Black church in Memphis was intentionally set, investigators say
Investigators determined the fire that severely damaged Memphis' historic Clayborn Temple, a key location during the 1968 sanitation workers' strike and linked to Martin Luther King Jr., was arson. The church, undergoing renovations, suffered interior damage, though the exterior may be salvaged. The arson investigation is ongoing.
View More

Entities

Tap or click for details
These entities are mentioned most frequently in the narratives highlighted in this brief. Click to see details of narrative activity related to each one.
People
Mark Tooley
A key figure whose views on Christianity and democracy are discussed.
The Robbs
Authors who exposed mainline denominations' Marxist leanings.
Novak
Defender of democratic capitalism cited by Tooley.
Neuhaus
Critic of unchecked clerical power referenced by Tooley.
Weber
Articulated Methodism's democratizing principles.
Butterfield
Emphasized historical patience and self-limitation, influencing Tooley.
Narratives
Christianity and democracy intersection
The central theme of Tooley's views shaped by various authors.
Democratic capitalism defense
Narrative supported by Novak.
Methodism's democratizing principles
Narrative articulated by Weber.
Historical patience and self-limitation
Narrative emphasized by Butterfield.
Decisions
Activism
Tooley's response to the ideas he encountered.
Role at the Institute on Religion and Democracy
Tooley's current position influenced by his views.
Controversies
Marxist leanings in mainline denominations
Exposé by the Robbs highlighting Marxist influences.
Unchecked clerical power
Critiqued by Neuhaus as a problem in religious institutions.
Denominations
Mainline denominations
Christian denominations with alleged Marxist leanings according to the Robbs.
Methodism
Christian denomination noted for its democratizing principles by Weber.
People
Mark Tooley
A key figure whose views on Christianity and democracy are discussed.
The Robbs
Authors who exposed mainline denominations' Marxist leanings.
Novak
Defender of democratic capitalism cited by Tooley.
Neuhaus
Critic of unchecked clerical power referenced by Tooley.
Weber
Articulated Methodism's democratizing principles.
Butterfield
Emphasized historical patience and self-limitation, influencing Tooley.
Narratives
Christianity and democracy intersection
The central theme of Tooley's views shaped by various authors.
Democratic capitalism defense
Narrative supported by Novak.
Methodism's democratizing principles
Narrative articulated by Weber.
Historical patience and self-limitation
Narrative emphasized by Butterfield.
Decisions
Activism
Tooley's response to the ideas he encountered.
Role at the Institute on Religion and Democracy
Tooley's current position influenced by his views.
Controversies
Marxist leanings in mainline denominations
Exposé by the Robbs highlighting Marxist influences.
Unchecked clerical power
Critiqued by Neuhaus as a problem in religious institutions.
Denominations
Mainline denominations
Christian denominations with alleged Marxist leanings according to the Robbs.
Methodism
Christian denomination noted for its democratizing principles by Weber.

Context

The intersection of Christianity and democracy, as reflected in Mark Tooley's views, touches on several broader societal and political dynamics. Demographically, many Western countries with significant Christian populations are experiencing shifts such as aging populations and increasing religious diversity, which influence the role of religion in public life. Socially, debates about the role of religion often intersect with issues of cultural identity, moral values, and social cohesion, especially as secularism and pluralism grow.

Economically, the critique of Marxist leanings within some mainline denominations highlights tensions between different economic ideologies. Democratic capitalism, defended by Novak, emphasizes free markets and individual rights, which are often seen as compatible with certain Christian ethical frameworks that value personal responsibility and charity. Politically, the concern about unchecked clerical power reflects ongoing debates about the separation of church and state, the influence of religious institutions on policy, and the balance between religious freedom and democratic governance.

Geographically, these issues are most pronounced in regions with strong Christian traditions, such as North America and Europe, where historical developments have shaped both religious institutions and democratic systems. National security considerations may arise when ideological conflicts within religious communities intersect with political extremism or social unrest, potentially affecting social stability.

Tooley’s engagement with these themes through activism and his role at the Institute on Religion and Democracy suggests an effort to influence public discourse and policy by advocating for a vision of Christianity that supports democratic principles, economic freedom, and restrained religious authority. This reflects broader global challenges where religion and democracy must coexist amid changing demographics, social values, and political pressures.
View More
View Less
World Events
Tap or roll over dots to see representative headlines
Created with Highcharts 11.1.0May 15May 16May 17May 18May 19May 20May 21May 22May 23May 24May 25May 26May 27May 28
Stock & Crypto Dynamics