Deep Sea Mining

Marine Mining

30 days

Summary

sources
30
Narrative Items
43
Bottom Line Up Front

30 sources in Marine Mining are amplifying 43 narrative items relating to the narrative of deep-sea mining's environmental implications and regulatory challenges. These narratives connect the discovery of 'dark oxygen' and its potential impact on marine ecosystems with the ongoing debates among Pacific nations, highlighting the tension between economic interests and ecological preservation.

Reviewing a number of the most relevant narrative items indicates that the portrayal of the deep-sea mining events varies significantly across different media sources. DIVE Magazine focuses on the implications of the "dark oxygen" discovery, presenting a balanced view that emphasizes scientific curiosity while cautioning about environmental impacts, using technical language and carefully constructed arguments. In contrast, Blue Planet Society highlights the environmental risks associated with deep-sea mining, employing emotionally charged language that presents a predominantly negative perspective on mining practices, showcasing clear bias against the industry. Meanwhile, Greenpeace also adopts a critical stance, specifically addressing the potential harm to marine life, framing the narrative around the vulnerability of whale species with vivid descriptions. Kaniva Tonga News offers a more nuanced perspective, illustrating the division among Pacific island nations on deep-sea mining, thereby providing a neutral account that acknowledges varying economic interests while also featuring local activism. Coverage by mining.com and Canadian Mining Journal presents a more industry-friendly narrative, emphasizing progress and economic benefits related to deep-sea mining, employing terms like "milestone" to frame developments positively. Environment & Energy Publishing and Daily Climate provide updates regarding leadership changes in international regulatory agencies, with Daily Climate hinting at deeper issues of governance through allegations of corruption. Overall, the differing use of language, emotional framing, and selective focus across these sources reveals significant disparities that can slant public perception of deep-sea mining activities and their consequences.

About This Module

This Marine Mining Experts module monitors sources who publish on the science, engineering, environment, economics, policy, and other aspects of marine mining.

Geospatial

Origin
Destination
This map shows narrative amplification activity by sources in this module.
The narrative initially emerged from Hoboken, headed for Mexico City. As it spread, the most frequent origin shifted to Washington, and the most frequent destination shifted to Nuku‘alofa. There are a total of 20 points of origin, and 28 destinations. Hide details...
21 Aug 2024: Hoboken ▸ Mexico City
21 Aug 2024: Tokyo ▸ Beijing
21 Aug 2024: Half Way Tree ▸ London
22 Aug 2024: Washington ▸ São Paulo
22 Aug 2024: Berlin ▸ Oslo
23 Aug 2024: Seattle ▸ Washington
23 Aug 2024: London ▸ Nuku‘alofa
25 Aug 2024: Nuku‘alofa ▸ Nuku‘alofa
26 Aug 2024: Washington ▸ Jakarta
28 Aug 2024: Honolulu ▸ Honolulu
28 Aug 2024: Kapaa ▸ Avarua
29 Aug 2024: Nuku‘alofa ▸ Nuku‘alofa
29 Aug 2024: Washington ▸ Moon
30 Aug 2024: Manchester ▸ Yaren
30 Aug 2024: Half Way Tree ▸ Kingston
30 Aug 2024: London ▸ Brisbane
01 Sep 2024: North Vancouver ▸ Jakarta
03 Sep 2024: Manchester ▸ Kavieng
03 Sep 2024: Tokyo ▸ Tokyo
05 Sep 2024: Melbourne ▸ Palau
06 Sep 2024: Hoboken ▸ Madison
06 Sep 2024: Lausanne ▸ Singapore
06 Sep 2024: Washington ▸ Hanoi
08 Sep 2024: Hoboken ▸ Madison
09 Sep 2024: Vancouver ▸ Hachinohe
09 Sep 2024: Toronto ▸ Hachinohe
10 Sep 2024: Hoboken ▸ California
10 Sep 2024: Manchester ▸ Tokyo
10 Sep 2024: Raleigh ▸ Port Moresby
12 Sep 2024: Washington ▸ Santa Barbara
12 Sep 2024: Coronado ▸ Colombia
18 Sep 2024: Houston ▸ Oslo
18 Sep 2024: Half Way Tree ▸ Cambridge
18 Sep 2024: Washington ▸ Ocean
19 Sep 2024: Holborn ▸ Melbourne

Themes

Tap or click for details
These adjacent themes are currently being amplified along with the main narrative
Comparison of Merrimack Pharmaceuticals and Seelos Therapeutics
Strong institutional ownership indicates long-term outperformance belief by hedge funds, endowments, and large money managers.
Pope Francis to Visit Indonesia in September 2024
Pope Francis is set to visit Indonesia on September 3, 2024, marking a significant honor for the Indonesian nation according to Minister of Religious Affairs, Yaqut Cholil Qoumas.
Leaders convene to address regional challenges
From August 26 to 30, Pacific Islands leaders are gathering in Tonga to reach a consensus on pressing issues affecting the region.
Initiatives for High Seas Treaty
Efforts are underway to implement fisheries closures and achieve the 60th ratification of the High Seas Treaty by 2025, demonstrating a proactive commitment to conservation.
Exploration of magmatic and amagmatic processes
This research examines both magmatic and amagmatic seafloor generation at the ultraslow-spreading Gakkel Ridge in the Arctic Ocean.
Impact of Consecutive Heat Extremes on Coral Recovery
Coral reefs are facing challenges in recovering from bleaching events due to shrinking gaps between heat extremes, impacting young colonies of heat-sensitive corals.

Sources

Tap or click for details
These sources are generating the most narrative activity
Pew Environment
9% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
Greenpeace
7% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
International Seabed Authority (ISA)
7% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
American Banking News
7% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
The Diplomat
5% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
The Guardian
5% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
Blue Planet Society
5% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
Kaniva Tonga News
5% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
The Wilson Center
2% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.
Conservation International
2% of the narratives in this brief were amplified by this source.

Entities

Tap or click for details
These entities are mentioned most frequently in the narratives highlighted in this brief
Organizations
International Seabed Authority
Agency overseeing deep-sea mining activities.
Civil Society Forum of Tonga
Organization leading protests against seabed mining.
Pacific Islands Association of NGOs
Group advocating for a moratorium on deep-sea mining.
Technologies
Deep-sea mining
Extraction of minerals from the ocean floor.
Satellite-based vessel tracking
Technology used to monitor mining vessel activities.
Companies
The Metals Company (TMC)
Company processing deep-sea nodules for battery and infrastructure metals.
PAMCO
Partnering with TMC to smelt processed nodules into valuable metals.
Events
Deep-sea mining operation off Papua New Guinea
Recent mining activity raising environmental concerns.
Protest against seabed mining
Led by the Civil Society Forum of Tonga and the Pacific Islands Association of NGOs.
People
Leticia Reis de Carvalho
Brazilian oceanographer elected to lead the International Seabed Authority.
Michael Lodge
Former head of the International Seabed Authority, under investigation for alleged corruption.

Top Items

These narrative items are the most relevant and/or the most amplified

Context

The discovery of "dark oxygen" in the bathypelagic zone has significant implications for deep-sea mining, particularly in regions like Papua New Guinea (PNG) and the broader Pacific. PNG, with a population of around 9 million, faces a complex interplay of economic development and environmental conservation. The country has rich mineral resources, and while deep-sea mining presents economic opportunities, it raises concerns about ecological impacts, especially on marine biodiversity and oxygen production.

Geographically, the Bismarck Sea is home to unique ecosystems, including hydrothermal vents that support diverse marine life. The potential disruption from mining activities threatens these habitats, particularly for vulnerable species like whales, which rely on sound for communication and navigation. The Pacific Islands are divided on mining; while some nations see it as a path to economic growth, others prioritize environmental protection, reflecting broader social and political tensions.

Economically, the push for deep-sea mining is driven by the demand for metals used in renewable energy technologies, such as electric vehicle batteries. However, the lack of comprehensive regulations in international waters complicates governance and raises national security concerns, as countries vie for control over lucrative resources.

Politically, the leadership of the International Seabed Authority is under scrutiny, with new leadership promising to address allegations of corruption and ensure responsible management of seabed resources. This reflects a growing recognition of the need for sustainable practices in resource extraction, balancing economic interests with environmental stewardship. As the global community grapples with climate change and resource scarcity, the future of deep-sea mining will require careful consideration of its ecological and social ramifications.
World Events
Tap or roll over dots to see representative headlines
Stock & Crypto Dynamics